Disorderly Conduct in Arizona
Disorderly conduct is one of the most common charges in Arizona. Police love to issue these charges because it is sort of a “catch-all” and can be charged in a wide variety of circumstances with not a lot of evidence.
This term is also known as “disturbing the peace,” which although common, is considered criminal. Circumstances deemed disorderly include unreasonable noise; causing a commotion to disrupt the order of business; reckless displays or handling of a firearm; fighting or disruptive behavior; failure to vacate an area when directed by law enforcement or other officials; and fighting or other disruptive behavior.
If you are charged with reckless display and handling of a firearm or other weapon considered harmful and potentially dangerous, the charge could easily be elevated to a class 6 felony, which carries a maximum penalty of one year in prison, and designation as a convicted felon.
Disorderly Conduct Arizona
There are several ways a person can be charged with Disorderly Conduct in Arizona, as detailed by the statute A.R.S. 13-2904, which details six different types of disorderly conduct. They are summarized here.
A person commits disorderly conduct in Arizona if, with intent to disturb the peace or quiet of a neighborhood, family or person, or with knowledge of doing so, such person:
As can be seen, this is very generic and not easy to interpret.
What exactly is disturbing the peace or quiet?
What is considered seriously disruptive behavior and who is the judge of what constitutes that conduct?
What type of noise is unreasonable?
What type of conduct is likely to provoke immediate retaliation and what exactly constitutes the likeliness of response
These are just a few questions that make this statute difficult to interpret. This is also a reason the police write a lot of these violations. The law is so broad that it can include virtually anything.
What are the penalties for disorderly conduct?
Most types of disorderly conduct are Class 1 Misdemeanors, except subsection 6, which involves the use of a firearm and raises the severity to become a Class 6 Felony.
A Class 1 Misdemeanor is highest classification of misdemeanor that exists in Arizona and carries the most serious potential penalties, which includes:
The potential penalties for being charged with disorderly conduct that involves a weapon are much more severe and includes a presumptive prison term of 1 year for a first offense felony. Probation may be eligible depending upon a person’s prior history.
When are people charged with disorderly conduct?
The most common situations we see people charged with disorderly conduct are under paragraphs 1 or 2, in situations involving fighting or making noise.
Most often, this happens in domestic situations where a couple or group of friends get into an argument and a neighbor or another person calls the police.
In the vast majority of cases, these are just temporary arguments or misunderstandings that do not require the police to be involved at all.
Unfortunately, when the police arrive it is almost a certainty that someone will be arrested as a result.
Another common situation where the police charge disorderly conduct is in nightlife locations, such as old town Scottsdale, where there is a lot of commotion and activity.
In some situations, an individual may have too much to drink and cause a disturbance. In other situations, people we work with are the victim of the conduct of another individual but are charged with disorderly conduct nonetheless.
In many situations involving nightlife, the police make little effort to actually investigate the cause of the problem, and instead arrest everyone and decide to let the courts sort it out later.
That approach unfortunately causes a lot of hardship to those who were not responsible nor contributed to the situation. In many cases they still face charges, have to consult with a lawyer, and risk having a criminal record over a situation that they did not cause.
What happens after an arrest for disorderly conduct?
As discussed above, people are commonly arrested for disorderly conduct.
Police do little to investigate and often blow situations completely out of proportion. Their philosophy is to make the arrest and let the prosecutor and the court deal with the rest of the case.
In most cases domestic situations, the person arrested for disorderly conduct will spend several hours or the night in jail until they see a judge, often the next morning.
The judge will often set release conditions, which may include not returning to the scene where the disorderly conduct is alleged to occur. This is massively disruptive, as in most cases this means the individual cannot return back to their place of residence.
These release conditions can be modified to allow the person to return back to their residence, but until the judge modifies the order that person may have to stay elsewhere.
In cases that do not involve a domestic dispute, the individual arrested may be released more quickly and told not to return to the scene, for example, a bar or a restaurant. They will be given a new court date in approximately 30 days.
What happens in Court for a disorderly conduct case?
Disorderly conduct, being a misdemeanor, follows the same criminal procedure as any other case. Meaning the case will progress alongside people charged with other offenses like DUI, assault, domestic violence, etc.
The first court date is most often an arraignment. This is where the Judge explains the maximum penalty and accepts either a plea of guilty or not guilty.
In most cases, the appropriate plea to enter is a plea of a not guilty, which allows the case to proceed forward. Pleading guilty closes the case and ends the possibility of providing a defense.
In some cases, the arraignment is completed while a person is in custody, and the next court date that is on the calendar is called a Pre-Trial Conference.
A Pre-Trial Conference is an proceeding in court between the prosecutor and the defense (either the defendant alone or the defendant’s attorney) that is informal in nature and which has the primary purpose of discussing issues that are developing in the case.
In a disorderly conduct situation, for example, our office requests everything the prosecutor has in their file that relate to the charges. This is called discovery, and when charged with a crime the defense has a legal right to access this material. It often includes:
- Police reports and officer notes
- Witness statements
- Dash cam or body cam footage
- Surveillance camera footage if occurring at an establishment 911 call recordings
- Impounded phone messages, text messages, voicemails
- Jail video recordings
All of this evidence is important to gather so the defense knows what exists and what each bit of evidence contains.
This material is requested prior to the pre-trial conference and often provided at this first setting. In some instances, this material is not available at the first setting but will trickle in as the case progresses.
It is not unusual to have several different pre-trial conferences to resolve issues. In most situations, the prosecutor will offer a plea agreement to resolve the case, but unless the plea provides a substantial benefit there may be no reason to accept the offer.
What are common defenses in a Disorderly Conduct case?
The strongest defenses center around the availability (or unavailability) evidence. In disorderly conduct situations, there is often nobody to actually testify against the person being accused.
For example, in a domestic situation, the entire case may have arisen from a misunderstanding or miscommunication. Often times, after the arrest has occurred, no one involved has any interest in seeing the case move forward.
The other people present may not want the person arrested to have a conviction or the people who called the police may have no interest in being involved in the case any further, since the situation has calmed down and resolved itself.
In these circumstances, certain rules of evidence prevent testimony from coming into court during a trial that would cause a court to find a person guilty.
In other situations, witness may not longer be around or interested in testifying. For example, bar bouncers or other patrons at an establishment may not be able to be contacted or may no longer be in Arizona as the case progresses.
Many people have no interest in spending their time involved in court proceedings, as they have their own lives to lead.
These are a few examples where the government and the prosecutors have weak or no evidence to move forward with their case.
There are many nuances and strategic considerations that must be taken into account to ensure these defenses are implemented properly, so it is important to consult with an attorney before moving to take a case to trial on this basis.
Since disorderly conduct can be subjective based on the circumstances, there are a number of defenses available to handle your case:
This comes into play when there are a number of witnesses who can testify on your behalf and challenge the claims and testimony of the arresting officer. If there is no concrete evidence brought forward, these charges may be dismissed.
Violation of Rights Granted by the Constitution
Freedom of speech does have some leeway. Citizens have a right to free speech and can assemble peacefully. IF it is proven that no abusive or offensive language was used, there is no case.
There are cases where some part of the case will prevent the prosecution from moving forward. These reasons vary from charges being pursued in the wrong jurisdiction, a time limit has elapsed, or some other cause that is a justifiably reasonable defense.
If the charge was brought against you while you were acting in self-defense due to you being provoked or threatened, we can work on your behalf to get those charges dropped.
Having the right team on your side makes a difference. The attorneys at The R&R Law Group are experienced in handling misdemeanor disorderly conduct cases in a swift and aggressive manner. You should never put yourself in a position where you feel that you have no recourse against the law. Getting representation should always be the first priority!
We work to protect your rights and look out for your best interest to make sure you have a winning chance at keeping your future bright and conviction free! For more information on how we can assist you in your time of need, contact an attorney at our law office today!
What are common outcomes in a disorderly conduct case?
Prosecutors often offer a plea agreement or a “deal” asking the person charged with the crime to plead guilty to the charge. They will argue that they could ask for jail time, but since they are not, there will be no jail time requested and therefore they are making a deal.
In reality, the vast majority of disorderly conduct cases to not rise to the level of seriousness or harm that would require jail or cause a judge to impose harsh penalties. In these cases the prosecutor’s offer is not a deal at all.
Instead, the prospect of trial and the lack of solid evidence create leverage in many situations that cause prosecutors to offer better deals.
In many situations, a better deal includes an offer known as diversion, where the case will ultimately be dismissed upon successful completion of classes or some other program. Depending on the nature of the case, these classes can range anywhere from 8 hours to 56 hours.
In some cases, prosecutors can be persuaded to dismiss the case entirely. As explained, the police very often arrest everyone in a close vicinity and decide to let the system sort it out later.
This results in innocent people being arrested. After an investigation that includes requesting videos, reports, completing interviews and building a defense, evidence can be persuasive enough to encourage a prosecutor to dismiss the case.
If the case is weak but the prosecutor is not willing to negotiate beyond offering a plea of guilt to disorderly conduct, our office encourages people we work with to take the case to trial to fight for a better result rather than accept a guilty plea.
What if this is my first disorderly conduct offense?
Once you are on the MVD site you want to select:
- Driver License Motor Vehicle Record – 39 Month Uncertified
A first offense disorderly conduct is more likely to be resolved with a diversion or a dismissal offer than another individual with prior convictions, but it is heavily dependent upon the specifics of the case. In some situations, a prosecutor will refuse to offer diversion despite having a first offense.
Our team helps people through a process known as mitigation, to help identify all the positive aspects of a person’s life beyond what happened during this incident. We discuss a person’s background, record, employment, family, future plans, special licenses, and other concerns.
The goal is to humanize the individual so that the court and the prosecutor know more about the person beyond what they see in the police report. This can be very helpful in the negotiation phase of the case.
I’ve been charged with Disorderly Conduct and want to speak with a Lawyer.
We can help! Our defense team practices exclusively in criminal defense and we do not take cases from any other field of law (family, business, personal injury).
We have helped hundreds of people charged with crimes like disorderly conduct successfully resolve their case, protect their record and fight for a winning outcome.
Hiring our office means it is very unlikely that you will have to attend court for the majority of the case. We may need you to be present one time at the end. Otherwise, our team handles all of the preliminary hearings on your behalf and we keep you apprised of all developments along the way.
Contact our office at (602) 737-2437 to schedule a complimentary case evaluation with our team.
Out-of-State Driver License Suspensions
“One Driver, One License, One Record”
If your driver license is suspended in one state, it is likely to be suspended in any other state you relocate.
This means that if your driver license is suspended in Arizona and you relocate and apply for a driver’s license in a different state, Arizona will report the suspension preventing you from obtaining a driver license in another state.
States communicate with each other of all driver license suspensions or revocations.
You will have to reinstate your driver license before you are able to obtain a license in a different state.
What states do not share driving records?
There are five states that do not share driving records:
This means that if you relocate to one of these states it is very possible to obtain a driver license regardless of the status in all other states.
How do I reinstate my driver’s license?
First you need to figure out why your license is suspended. You can obtain this information several different ways.
Correspondence from MVD: MVD will mail a corrective action letter to the address they have on record.
This will be the address you listed on your driver’s license.
The letter will explain why your license is suspended, when the suspension began or will begin, and what you can do to correct this situation.
Therefore, it is crucial to update your address with MVD every soon as you relocate.
Below is a sample of a corrective letter.
This record will reflect your information, i.e. name, date of birth, driver license number (customer number), issued and expiration dates, weight, height, sex, and address.
It will list any restrictions and endorsements on your driver license.
It will have the details of your driver licenses and at the bottom of the report it will reflect all violations for the last 39 months.
This is the part of the report that will reflect any suspension to your driver license.
Contact MVD: You can contact MVD directly at (602) 255-0072 or you can go to your local MVD.
The following website lists all MVD office locations in Arizona:
I have to travel to Arizona to reinstate my driver license?
If you have relocated, you can reinstate your driver license on line by going to the following website:
Please keep in mind that you can only reinstate your driver license if eligible. This means that you must address the reason why the suspension was ordered in the first place.
Is there a fee to reinstate my driver’s license?
The fee to reinstate your license in Arizona is usually $50.00. This does not include any fee you might have to pay to a Court.